My Life with God

The Changing Church

As I recently attended church online, a church leader used a phrase that made me cringe. He thanked the “audience online” for tuning in. I believe the intention was to include and welcome everyone not in the room, but the word audience made it sound as if those not in the room were less invested in the experience. It’s an arguable point. The in-person experience is different than the online experience. I love gathering with people, but I haven’t yet returned. It’s for a variety of reasons, which have shifted over time. In fact, it’s been a bit confusing at times, but I’m beginning to understand and embrace my hesitation. I won’t share the specifics, because I don’t want different reasons to cause a distraction.

What I know is this: I am becoming increasingly passionate about how the church engages and cultivates people.

I’ve been in church for a long time. I’ve worked with ministries around the country. I’ve served on staff and as a volunteer in the local church. And I have seen some good practices and some poor practices. Gaining the perspective prompted by the shifts due to the pandemic have revealed a lot about individuals, businesses, organizations, and…church. Strengths have been revealed. So have weaknesses.

Before you begin to declare, “But everyone should be in church, and once everyone realizes that, and we’re allowed to do what we want to do, it will all straighten out,” Realistically, we’re not returning to what we’ve done in the past, not just because of a pandemic, but because change happens over time. Look at the changes over the past decade and a decade before that…and before that and so on. (If you don’t see many changes, that might be another problem to face.)

I’ve seen a bit of a snap of a rubber band through this rather unique year. Many churches scrambled to think creatively to reach people within the confines of what was safe and possible. Churches helped each other, shared ideas, and came up with some great solutions. God provided through resources and creativity. Flexibility reigned, even among many who are generally resistant to change. Then we got a reprieve. We could return to some of our previous ways. And that was good, except that it paused the creativity. Because we were no longer in crisis mode—and let’s be honest, many staff and volunteers were exhausted—we tried to gather up as many remnants as we could to move forward. Once we started seeing people in person again…wait, what happened to everyone else?

It became easy to excuse some people didn’t feel safe gathering yet or some had gotten out of the routine and would return once other aspects of their lives returned to normal. But what if we continued to intentionally engage online? If online became a side thought of “sure, we’ll keep offering it,” but most opportunities were offered in person, if Sunday morning online worship services were the only chance to engage instead of weekday or anytime on-demand opportunities, we will continue to lose more and more people. And I’m not talking about attendance. It’s not a numbers game. It’s a faith-building gain or loss.

We can argue people should engage in a specific way, reset priorities, be responsible, but isn’t that a bit naïve (and judgmental)? Yes, we need to help others grow. Every one of us needs to be challenged. But as the church, let’s not be so limiting as to think we can only experience and equip within the confines of a building or timeframe. We need to serve and reach and grow (ourselves and others) better than that.

Jesus didn’t have the same technology we have, but he certainly didn’t do the majority of his ministry at a specific time in a building.

I think we can learn a lot from him.

6 thoughts on “The Changing Church”

  1. We tried this Sunday again to return to church instead of worshiping online. Concerns were present. I so desire to shake the sense that I’m not worshiping correctly until I get back to the church building. It’s almost a guilty feeling. I want to learn what God is teaching me through this new way of engaging.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. I believe it’s important to dig into the reasons for our guilty feelings, because guilt can get misconstrued. It can make us think we’re supposed to go in one direction when it’s fear or expectations or legalism that’s at the core. The guilt you feel might indeed be God prompting you to worship in a specific way, but it also might be more of the habit you’re accustomed to. I am in no way saying avoiding in person worship is okay as a chronic habit. However, I believe and have experienced God moving in people’s lives when there is intention even outside of the traditional setting during this odd season. The COVID challenges are no surprise to God, only us…and now they are not surprising but tiring and frustrating. What is important is our pursuit of God in any circumstance. If we’re not growing, there’s a problem (but sometimes we simply don’t feel as if we’re growing through seasons of rest and preparedness but there is indeed progress of faith). Often, not growing is less about what we’re doing/not doing (e.g. not growing can happen within the four walls of the building as much as outside) and more about our stance of humility in trusting God to do what he knows is best in and through us.
      I am praying for you to continue to lean into God each week, each day, each moment.

      Like

  2. I will be honest, we actually have watched online for well over a year. Why? Because I was just as concerned about catching the flu or even a cold, which for me always turns into 6 weeks or more of hacking bronchitis and misery. And where do people go when they are sick, come what may? Besides the grocery store and pharmacy, CHURCH. Because they believe they will be blessed by being there in person and praised by God for their attendance, when in actuality they should be more concerned about spreading illness to others. (Sorry, my nurse brain never shuts off.)

    Another point you make keeps bouncing in my brain. “It’s not a numbers game. It’s a faith-building gain or loss.”

    Too often I think people equate church attendance with growth. When what is really happening is a glorifying of human goals. Not the same thing at all.
    Thanks for posting this. I think you are bringing out some very valid points here.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks. Speaking of grocery stores and pharmacies…I went to the pharmacy yesterday to get my flu shot, and I had to chuckle at the oddity of a little crowd in the back of the pharmacy (well space though) in an attempt to try to stay well in a season we are trying to stay away from germs!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Right?? Unfortunately since I am having issues with my hives, they won’t give me my shot right now. Hoping this clears up soon so I can get it! Not happy at this turn of events!

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s